Wednesday, February 12, 2014

Critically evaluate Romanticism Topic Literary Criticism

The words ‘Romanticism’ and ‘Classicism’ are regarded as the contrasting terms. But the term ‘classical’ and ‘Romantic’ are not synonyms of ‘classicism’ and ‘Romanticism’. The words ‘classical’ and ‘Romantic’ show his two attitudes of mind towards life and its expression in the art. While the words ‘classicism’ and ‘romanticism’ refer to two specific movements in relatively modern time.
In them two attitudes to life and to art came to be formulated as ideology, as a creed or cult with its manifestation, its body of doctrine and a name. Each of these movements was a revival – conscious attempt to return to the art form. Classicism was born of the Renaissance rediscovery of Greek and the desire to imitate Greek and Roman literature and art. But there have always been Romantics even in classical’ Greek. Romanticism is the name given to the late 18th and early 19th century reaction against classicism. It was in its origin an attempts return to what was believed to have been the spirit of the middle Ages.

Classical and Romantic:-
          ‘Classical’ this word dates from the Renaissance and come from Latin. It means
To describe everything, belonging to cultures of Greek and Rome (e.g. their language, art, philosophy etc.)
Any work of art produced in imitation of forms of Greek and Roman art.
The word is used in the sense of highest range.
Romantic: - The word Romance originally indicated a language derived from the Roman. The name the language became attached to the subjects matter. Then it was extended to include tales chivalry and of the marvelous. It was Romantic Movement which gave it its present meaning.

The Romanticism:-
          Various people define this Romanticism in various ways.
          Romanticism is disease, classicism in health. – Goethe.
          The return to nature – Rousseall
          The movement to honour whatever classicism rejected. Classicism is the regularity of good sense perfection in moderation; Romanticism is disorder in the imagination the rage of incorrectness. A blind wave of literary egotism. – Brumetiere.
          The opposite not of classicism but of Realism – a withdrawal from outer experience to concentrate upon inner. – Abercrombie.
          “The Reawakening of the life and thought of the Middle Ages. – Heine.
          Emotion rather than reason; the heart opposed to the head. – George Sand.
          Subjectivity, the love of the picturesque and a reactionary spirit (against whatever immediately preceded it) - Phelps. 
          “Romanticism” and “classicism’ both are ideologies. Both were conscious and deliberate breaks with tradition. Both were not working within a living tradition. Both were trying to revive an earlier tradition which was unfamiliar to their contemporaries. The younger generation was becoming restless. They were hungry for change. The results we know.
          “Rules’ were dominant in ‘classicism’ while ‘rejection of the rule’ was the mark of the Romantic Movement. Rule had become a tyranny, inhabiting the ‘free play of the imagination. As it always happens in revolutionary movement, the pendulant swing to the opposite extreme. For them the rules were evil and must be abandon in favour of imagination. Thought there were no rules, there were certain principles about which every romanticist agreed. They are as following.

Imagination:-
          Imagination was something new in the history of thought. Every creative artist has always known that art is born of imagination. To the ‘Romanists’ the imagination was not only the source of all poetry but its sole creator of not only poetry but civilization morality and religion. It came to be regarded as an ‘inner light’. This cult of imagination became something like a religious faith. This concept was revolutionary.

(2) Individualism:-
          The second principle which all Romanticists shared was ‘Individualism’. This was already implicit in the revolt against externally imposed rules and the claim to individual liberty. But the implicit was made explicit and justified by philosophical doctrine. This doctrine was provided in the first place by Rousseau and by his disciple Godwin. Both taught the perfectibility of man through the rule of reason. To Rousseau and Godwin everyman was absolutely rational, it was necessary to create a just society from which all evils would be banished. Godwin’s ‘political Justice’ was considered as a ‘Bible’ of English Romanticism. He felt that abolition of law and government will set individual to be free to follow the light of his own reason.

(3) Subjectivity:-
          The classicists look outward for his truth; it is same for all men. But to the Romantic truth lay within himself. What his imagination revealed to him must be accepted though all the world rejected it.

(4) Preference to ‘Particular’:-
          The classicists preferred ‘general’ while the ‘Romanticists’ preferred ‘particular’. For them every humanbeing was unique and the type was non existent. Even Wordsworth and Coleridge believed that despite universality there was individuality in every human being.

(5) Sensibility: -
          Wordsworth defined the poet as ‘a man with more lively sensibility.’ We find passionate feelings in his poetry. The Greeks believed in the Golden Mean, the middle way between too much passion and too little. To the romantics emotion tended to be good in itself. Only in a state of heightening feeling, whether of pleasure or pain, was a man truly alive.

The source of Inspiration for Romanticists:-
          There are some sources from which the Romanticists got their inspirations.

(A) Medievalism: - (The Gothic Revival)
          To the classicists of the 18th century the word ‘Gothic’ was equivalent to barbarous; the middle Ages were the Dark Ages. To the Romanticists the Middle Ages became a world of enchantment. Gothic stood for all the aspiration the mystery, spirituality and wonder. This idealization of the Middle Ages had various manifestations as follows.
 The Gothic revival in architecture. In the full flood the Romantic Movement. Gothic became the only acceptable style of architecture.
 In narrative poetry, use of stories in a medieval setting. e.g. Coleridge’s ‘Charitable’, Keats’s ‘Isabella’ and ‘The Eve of St. Agnes’.
 In prose fiction the ‘Gothic romance’, a fantastic tale of adventure, marvel and the supernatural in Gothic setting. e.g. Horace Walpole’s ‘The castle of Otranto’.
 The rediscovery of ‘ballads’ e.g. Percy’s ‘Reliques of Ancient English Poetry.’ The others are ‘The Ancient Mariner’, ‘La Belle Dame Sans Merce’.
 The interest in supernatural e.g. ‘The Ancient Mariner’, ‘La Belle Dame Sans Merce’, ‘Lamia’ etc.


Geographical Exploration (Step in Explorative land):-
          There was an escape from the familiar and hence escape from prosaic, known world into unknown and hence mysterious parts of the earth.
 Tales of voyages into unknown; again ‘The Ancient Mariner’
 Exoticism’: especially the highly coloured oriental exotic. ‘Kubla Khan’ is far more than exotic but its setting in xanadee is essentially romantic.

(C)Nature:-
          The escape from the city, limited, man-made, known to the infinite wonders of nature, untouched by man. E.g. Shelly’ ‘Mont Blanc’, Byron’s ‘Manfred’, words worth’s ‘prelude’.

(d) The primitive:-
          This comes from Rousseau’s Noble Savage. He and his followers believed that civilization destroys man’s native innocence.

(E) Utopianism:-
The escape from the limitations the imperfect present into a dream of a Golden Age of human perfectibility in an unknown future. e.g. Shelley ‘s ‘Prometheus unbound’.

The macabre:-
A product of the cult of emotionalism. Evil, death and the horrible were treated in order to exile emotion. The school boy shelly haunted grave yards. (Hymn to Intellectual Beauty.)

(G) Political liberty; republicanism:-
          Almost every romanticist was for a time at least, a republican. Rousseau began it with is doctrine of the General will. France Revaluation add more such spirit.
          There are the main direction in which the romantic spirit set out to explore the mysteries and wonders.

Classical Versus Romantic:-
          We need both the classical and the Romantic, Sophocles and Racine as well as Shakespeare, Homer, Milton as well as Wordsworth. Without either group we should be poor. Each has the defects its qualities. They carry within themselves the seeds of decay. Too much following of rules affected classicists and too much imagination affected Romanticists. The great romantics have explored realms which no classical writer would dare to enter. They have extended the range of human sensibility. At this time, some dangers are revealed. e.g. egotism, self-pity, a pride in being different and at war with society, escapism, sentimentality, irrationality etc. When these became predominant the pendulum swung back to classical rationality, objectively and discipline.



No comments:

Post a Comment